Turner Prize 2010: Sweet Music or a Lot of Noise?
// December 7th, 2010 // View Comments // b-scene
The first ever ‘sound installation’ to win the famed, Turner Prize was announced at London’s Tate Britain last night.
Susan Philipsz’s eight-minute recording of Scottish lament, Lowlands Away, was recorded in her native Glasgow under three bridges and is played out to an empty gallery in the Tate, the faint sounds of student protesters an unintentional accompaniment.
Hardly visual art, but what artistic merit does this piece have?
I find it hard to be inspired by what is essentially a pre recorded song, played out in an empty room. The Turner Prize has always been known for being a bit ‘edgy’ or ‘wacky’, dependant on your view. But have the judging panel gone too far this year and helped to distance modern art from the average person?
Previous winning entries, such as Tracey Emin’s ‘My Bed‘ in 1999 and Martin Creed’s ‘Lights On, Lights Off’ in 2001, were ridiculed in the press and by the average person for their perceived lack of any real technique and their randomness. After all, many a house contains a messy bed and indeed, the flickering of lights!
So what constitutes art in today’s modern world and how far removed has the kind of modern art celebrated by the Turner Prize become from the general persons perception of what art should really be?
Today’s art has obviously moved on from Michelangelo, Picasso and the like, but is this for the better or the worse?
One thing is for certain, ‘Lowlands Away’ certainly won’t be making it on to my iPod in a hurry!



















